Home arrow Home arrow Decibel politics - RaviShankar and Zakir Hussain
rot_navtej2.jpg
Decibel politics - RaviShankar and Zakir Hussain PDF Print E-mail
Tag it:
Delicious
Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Technorati
BlinkList
Written by Administrator   
Sunday, 19 February 2006

RaviShankar and Zakir
Photo courtesy:the Hindu

MUMBAI: The event was rare. They were getting together after a very long number of years for some great music, which was not to be. The event turned shocking with Sitar maestro Pandit Ravi Shankar accusing tabla whiz Ustad Zakir Hussain of "unprofessional and immature" conduct while performing with him at Shanmukhananda Hall here on Saturday evening.
In the middle of the concert and in front of a shocked audience of 3,000-odd music lovers, Zakir Hussain yanked the microphone from its stand in front of his tablas . Panditji was playing Maaj Khamaaj at the time. Hussain was upset with the quality of the tabla sound. He had indicated to the sound technician that the volume of his microphone should be adjusted, but apparently nothing was done. Zakir's act upset the audience since it could only hear Ravi Shankar and his daughter Anoushka. They kept up a steady chant of "We want tabla", following which Zakir put the microphone back in its place and continued playing.

Shocked by Zakir's behaviour , Ravi Shankar says "I have known him since he was a kid. I did not expect this from him. These days some artistes play fusion music and suchlike and are used to loud music. As an instrumentalist, I like the sound of the accompanists to be about 20 per cent lower than the volume of my sitar.
This is standard practice. If at all he had a problem, he should have indicated it to me. But his behaviour was totally unjustified"

An office-bearer of the Shanmukhananda Sabha blamed Ravi Shankar's wife, Sukanya, for the commotion. "She interfered with the sound arrangements and kept instructing the sound in-charge so as to highlight the performance of Panditji and Anoushka."
We have spent about Rs 2 crore on Shanmukhananda's acoustics and it is the best in the country. If we had been allowed to handle the system there would have been no problem," he added.
Sukanya, however, refuted the charge. "I don't know anything about sound engineering. But as a music lover, I felt that something was wrong with the music emerging from Zakir's mike.

I was sitting next to tabla artiste Tapan Bose and asked him if Zakir's sound was okay. He told me that it was not and that is when I told the sound in-charge to raise Zakir's volume.
How can this be construed as interference? My husband and daughter Anoushka were playing and I only wanted the best quality music.

This altercation would not have happened had it not been for the unseemly behaviour of Zakir. No matter what his celebrity status happens to be, every seasoned musician knows in his heart that the music he performs is far more significant than his own persona. Has one noticed the placement of different instruments in a symphony or an orchestra? Whether it is western or an Indian classical music, the existence of an heirarchy among different instruments is indisputable, though subtle. Nobody refutes the fact that the Shruti box or the Tanpura that plays unobtrusively in the background along with the vocalist or an instrumentalist is as important as the vocalist or the instrumentalist. This argument in no way diminishes the role that the Shruti box or the Tanpura performs in overall success of the event but restate an order of importance that is integral to the success of a musical performance.


The Tabla in the Indian classical music tradition has always been an accompaniment and has never shared the same status as a Sitar or a Sarod or a Veena. The present generation of seasoned tabla players do not subscribe to this school of thought. One of the reason for this stems from the fact that most of these Tabla players are involved in Jazz and fusion music. Jazz and fusion music has ample provision for the tabla players to showcase their talent to a huge international audience. Tabla-players who perform in these Jazz and Fusion events should not allow their ego, relevant in one realm, to impinge on their secondary role in Indian classical
music.

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 01 March 2006 )
 
< Prev   Next >
WoW Directory Search Engine and Directory Service
|Disclaimers| |Privacy Policy|
© 2008 Vimoksha - Indian classical music and dance portal